5 Real-world cyber claims that show why cyber insurance matters

Agents must be appointed with LocalEdge prior to submitting a quote request.

If you are not currently appointed, please click below to start the appointment process.

Appointed and ready to quote?

Cyber claims aren’t just affecting large corporations anymore. From phishing scams and ransomware attacks to software errors and fraudulent wire transfers, businesses of all sizes are experiencing cyber-related losses that can reach hundreds of thousands of dollars. Sharing real claim examples is one of the best ways agents can help customers understand why cyber insurance deserves a place in every risk conversation.

1. Ransomware shuts down operations

A data storage provider specializing in e-commerce businesses experienced a cyber breach that compromised critical customer data. The attackers demanded a $1.3 million ransom to restore systems and prevent the release of sensitive information. With the help of the company’s cyber insurance carrier and breach response team, negotiations reduced the ransom payment to $425,000, while additional expenses included forensic investigations, legal fees, notification costs, public relations support, and regulatory matters. The total claim exceeded $642,500.*

Lesson for customers: Recovering from ransomware involves much more than restoring data. Business interruption, legal expenses, regulatory issues, and reputation management can quickly become the largest costs.

2. Employee falls for a phishing email

A professional services firm received what appeared to be a legitimate request from a trusted vendor. After updating payment information, an employee unknowingly transferred company funds to a fraudulent account.

Potential financial impact: Wire transfer fraud and phishing incidents commonly result in tens of thousands of dollars in direct financial loss, in addition to forensic investigations and recovery efforts.

Lesson for customers: Even well-trained employees can fall victim to increasingly sophisticated phishing attacks.

3. Customer data breach leads to notification costs

A retail business discovered unauthorized access to its customer database, exposing customer information. Beyond restoring systems, the company faced expenses for customer notifications, credit monitoring, legal counsel, forensic investigations, and public relations support.

Potential financial impact: Even relatively small breaches can easily cost six figures once notification requirements, legal fees, and response services are factored in.

Lesson for customers: The costs associated with a breach often extend far beyond the technology itself.

4. Technology errors & omissions can become a cyber claim

A software development company was sued after a customer alleged delays and software defects prevented its inventory management system from functioning properly. Although the software company disputed the allegations, the matter resulted in legal defense costs, settlement negotiations, and reputation management expenses. The insurance carrier ultimately covered $342,350 in total costs, including a $276,000 settlement, legal expenses, and public relations fees.*

Lesson for customers: Cyber risks aren’t always caused by hackers. Technology failures, software errors, and professional liability claims can also result in significant financial losses.

5. Social engineering results in fraudulent wire transfer

A construction company received what appeared to be an urgent email from a project manager requesting payment for building materials. The email had been spoofed by a cybercriminal, and by the time the fraud was discovered, the funds had already been transferred.

Potential financial impact: Social engineering and business email compromise claims frequently result in $50,000 to several hundred thousand dollars in unrecoverable funds, depending on the size of the transfer.

Lesson for customers: Criminals don’t always need to hack a network—they often exploit trust instead.

Turning cyber claims into customer conversations

Cyber threats continue to evolve, and coverage options can vary depending on a customer’s operations, industry, and specific exposures. If your customers have questions about cyber insurance or you’re looking for guidance on available solutions, connect with our Commercial Lines team or learn more about cyber insurance and view our appetite guide here. We’re here to help you evaluate risks, navigate coverage options, and find the right cyber insurance solution for your customers.

Sources
IBM – Cost of a Data Breach Report (industry benchmark)
Coalition Cyber Claims Report (cyber insurance trends)
*Cyber Claim Scenarios (General) PDF (claim examples)

Talk to our cyber team today to get started on your next cyber submission.

Connect with our brokers to review cyber coverage options, and ensure your customers are protected.

Call us at 800.444.1744, Option 1, then 4. Or email at [email protected].